Does Semrush do competitor analysis?

Does Semrush do competitor analysis?

Short answer: Yes - and it works best as a structured workflow, not a magic wand. If you’re asking about Semrush competitor analysis, this guide walks through exactly how to use Semrush reports together, what thresholds to trust, how to validate findings with your own analytics, and how to turn data into decisions you can act on.

This article covers a reproducible approach built from practical experience: the reports to run (Domain Overview, Organic Research, Keyword Gap, Backlink Analytics, Traffic Analytics, Market Explorer), the filters and thresholds that separate noise from meaningful overlap, and the validation steps that make conclusions reliable. You’ll see examples, checklists and tips to avoid common traps.

Why Semrush is useful - and where it needs your judgement

Semrush consolidates many public signals in one place. It gives visibility estimates, ranked keywords, link profiles and traffic approximations that are excellent for comparison. For many teams, Semrush competitor analysis becomes the fastest way to create a shortlist of rivals and spot advantage gaps.

<figure class="special-image-standalone">
  <a href="/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">
    <img src="/img/blog/7ac53d7a356d418c.jpg" alt="Orvus Ltd. Logo" />
  </a>
</figure>

How to use this article

Follow the step‑by‑step workflow below. Each step includes practical thresholds, examples and export recommendations you can copy into a shared spreadsheet. If you prefer a template, ask for the reproducible spreadsheet and filter presets after you read this.

Start with a clear question

Competitor analysis begins with a precise target. Ask: Who are my true competitors for the queries that drive conversions? Don’t confuse topical peers (sites that write about the same subject) with direct commercial rivals (sites trying to win the same customers).

For most commerce teams, the useful question is: which sites share a meaningful proportion of my transactional and high‑intent keywords? That is what we will measure.

Quick tip: When you want help turning data into a prioritized action plan, teams often pair this workflow with a strategic partner like Orvus services for technical audits and link research - a careful, embedded approach that focuses on the business outcomes rather than checkbox audits.

Which Semrush reports to use (and why)

Use this set of reports together - each one fills an essential gap in the picture:

Semrush's how-to guide on competitor analysis is a useful companion if you want additional context on the report workflows described below.

Domain Overview

Fast snapshot: estimated organic traffic, number of ranking keywords, paid presence and top pages. Great for an initial sense of whether a domain operates at a similar scale to yours.

Organic Research - Positions

See which keywords a competitor ranks for, landing pages and position trends. Useful to spot whether competitors are gaining ground on long‑tail variations or hijacking your high‑value queries.

Keyword Gap

Compare up to several domains at once to find shared keywords, unique keywords and gaps. This tool makes overlap concrete - the numbers you use to classify direct competitors vs topical peers.

Backlink Analytics

Shows link sources and the pages attracting links. A robust backlink profile that points to a product or category page signals durable ranking strength, not just a viral article spike.

Traffic Analytics

An independent estimate of visits and referral channels. Use it to check seasonality, referral patterns and whether a competitor draws traffic from the same channels your audience uses.

Market Explorer

Gives market‑level context: is the market concentrated, or fragmented? Market Explorer helps you decide whether to focus on a few direct rivals or many niche players.

A step‑by‑step workflow for reliable results

Below is the reproducible, seven‑step workflow that many in‑house teams and consultants use. Apply it quarter‑ly for stable markets and monthly for fast‑moving categories.

Step 1 - Prepare your seed list and scope

Gather 8-12 candidate domains from search results, sales feedback and customer insights. Define the geography (country) and device focus (mobile or desktop) in Semrush before you start - results vary by both.

Step 2 - Quick filtering with Domain Overview

Run Domain Overview for each candidate and record three metrics: estimated organic traffic, number of ranking keywords and number of referring domains. These numbers help you exclude very small or irrelevant sites quickly.

Example: If a competitor reports 10x your estimated traffic but only 5% keyword overlap with your commercial pages, they may be a topical behemoth rather than a direct product competitor.

Step 3 - Quantify overlap with Keyword Gap

Use Keyword Gap to compare your domain to the top 4-6 candidates. Filter to keywords with commercial intent (terms like buy, best, review, price, shipping, near me) and export the shared and unique counts. Convert counts into percentages relative to each site’s total ranking keywords to find meaningful overlap.

A practical rule of thumb: treat 15-25% overlap (in meaningful commercial keywords) as a strong signal of direct competition. Below 10% is usually a topical peer unless the market is extremely niche.

Step 4 - Inspect Positions for the overlapping keywords

Open Organic Research → Positions for the overlapping keywords. For each high‑value keyword, note the landing page and the ranking history. Are competitors gaining on you? Are they ranking with product pages or generic blog content? Export a short list of the top 30 overlapping, high‑intent queries.

The answer depends on intent and overlap. If a large brand ranks across many verticals but shares only a tiny set of your commercial queries, a small niche retailer with 25-40% overlap is a more urgent competitor. Context matters.

Step 5 - Backlink context

Check which pages on competitor sites earn links and whether those pages correspond to product or category pages. A strong link profile for product pages suggests a durable ranking advantage. If most links point to blog posts, the visibility may be less durable or easier to replicate with outreach.

Step 6 - Traffic patterns and Market Explorer

Use Traffic Analytics to see seasonality and top referral sources. Market Explorer helps you decide how concentrated the market is. If a few players dominate both search and referrals, you’ll need a different competitive plan than if the market is fractured into many small stores.

Step 7 - Validate with your first‑party data

Triangulation is essential. Compare Semrush’s reported top landing pages to the queries and landing pages that actually drive your organic conversions in Search Console and GA4. If overlap in Search Console confirms Semrush’s estimates for a set of high‑value keywords, act on it. If Semrush shows a competitor ranking for a keyword that drives no conversions for you, deprioritize it.

Concrete thresholds and nuanced rules

Here are practical thresholds you can use as a starting point. They’re not laws - adapt them to your niche.

Keyword overlap: 15-25% of actively ranking, commercially relevant keywords = likely direct competitor. 10% and below = topical peer in many cases. In narrow niches, 5-10% can still be meaningful.

Traffic proximity: If Traffic Analytics shows competitor visits within 25-50% of your site’s visits (same region/timeframe), that’s additional evidence of direct competition. For global brands or marketplaces, focus on filtered subsets of keywords with commercial intent.

Backlink signals: Product pages with multiple editorial links are a durable signal. If competitor authority is concentrated in ephemeral pages, the advantage may be easier to challenge.

Sample scenario to make it tangible

Imagine you sell artisanal coffee gear. You test five domains. One is a big lifestyle publisher that ranks for many coffee terms but only overlaps 8% with your product keywords - a topical peer. A specialist retailer shows 32% keyword overlap and product landing pages that match your catalog - that’s a direct competitor. A subscription review site shows 18% overlap with higher traffic - a competitor in the consideration phase. You now prioritize the specialist retailer for product page optimizations and target review site queries with comparison and trust content.

Common pitfalls and how to avoid them

1. Confusing size with direct threat. Big sites rank broadly but may not compete for your transactional queries. Focus on the subset of keywords that matter to conversions.

2. Trusting single metrics. Don’t rely solely on estimated traffic or raw keyword counts. Combine multiple signals and validate with your own analytics.

3. Ignoring intent. Two sites may share many informational keywords but diverge on transactional terms. For commercial strategies, prioritize buying intent keywords.

Advanced filters and practical Keyword Gap settings

To get useful results quickly, filter Keyword Gap by:

- Intent: transactional or commercial modifiers (buy, best, review, price, coupon, near me).
- Volume floor: exclude very low‑volume queries that create noise.
- SERP features: if you rely on featured snippets or shopping carousels, prioritize queries that show those features.

Sort by estimated traffic value or difficulty if your Semrush plan shows those columns. Export the top 200 overlapping queries and prioritize the top 20 by conversion likelihood. For additional tactical detail, see this walkthrough: How to do competitor analysis with Semrush.

Export, record and iterate

Export raw reports where possible, but if your plan limits exports, save screenshots of the key views and manually record the most important metrics. Keep a simple shared spreadsheet with columns: competitor, estimated traffic, ranking keywords, overlapping commercial keywords (count + %), top overlapping queries, top overlapping landing pages, backlink notes, validation status (Search Console/GA4), and priority (High/Medium/Low).

How to validate: real‑world checks that make findings reliable

Validation is the difference between data and decision. Use these checks:

- Cross‑check shared keywords in Search Console.
- Compare top landing pages in Semrush to landing pages that actually receive organic conversions.
- Run a manual SERP check for 10 representative queries to see actual ranking pages and SERP features.
- Check referral reports: do referral domains match Semrush’s top referrers?

If three of these checks align for a set of top overlapping keywords, your confidence is high.

When Semrush is less reliable

Semrush estimates get noisy for:

- Very small sites or micro niches with thin search volumes.
- Local businesses with highly localized queries where sampling differs by city.
- Sites that depend heavily on non‑search channels (app traffic, internal apps, private communities).

In these cases, rely more heavily on first‑party data and manual checks.

Measuring success and evolving your tracking

Once you decide who matters, set measurable KPIs tied to search outcomes. Typical measures include:

- Organic conversions by category (monthly).
- Movement on priority overlapping queries (positions and share of voice).
- Market share estimates within Market Explorer categories.

Recompute overlap and progress on a cadence that matches your business: monthly for rapid categories, quarterly for stable ones.

Practical tactics once you identify direct competitors

After you confirm a direct competitor using Semrush competitor analysis, consider these responses:

- Technical fixes and architecture changes to ensure category pages are indexable and correctly structured.
- Content refreshes for top overlapping queries focused on commercial intent (clear CTAs, product schemas, comparison tables).
- Demand capture via paid search for queries where the competitor outranks you and conversions are proven.
- Link campaigns targeted at the same editorial referrers that send traffic to competitor product pages.

How Orvus helps (a subtle, tactical mention)

<div class="side-by-side special-image-left">
  <a href="/#about" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><img src="/img/blog/8dbc0d412b803dd6.jpg" alt="Minimalist analyst desk with laptop showing SEO graphs and charts, clean notebook and branded accents in #C8A45D on #0B1E33 background - Semrush competitor analysis" /></a>
  <div class="side-text"><p>For teams that need hands‑on help converting the analysis into prioritized technical and editorial actions, Orvus focuses on the parts that compound: search architecture, measurement fixes and automation that reduce ongoing maintenance. They typically step in when a brand needs deeper audits and systems rather than one‑off recommendations. A small logo can support consistent brand recognition across outreach and assets.</p></div>
</div><h2><b>Automation and scaling</b></h2><p>If you run this process often and at scale, consider automations:</p><p>- Scheduled exports from Semrush (or API pulls) into a shared data sheet.<br>- Scripts that compute overlap percentages and alert when a competitor&rsquo;s overlap increases beyond a threshold.<br>- Dashboards that combine Semrush estimates with Search Console and GA4 to surface verified overlaps.</p><p>Smarter automation reduces busywork and keeps the team focused on the high‑leverage actions.</p><h2><b>Expanded case study: outdoor gear retailer (detailed)</b></h2><p>A midsize outdoor gear retailer initially tracked two big marketplaces as main competitors. Using Semrush, they ran Domain Overview and Keyword Gap on seven domains. Two surprising facts surfaced: the marketplaces had broad visibility but only 12% overlap on commercial queries; a regional retailer showed 35% overlap and had strong referral traffic from niche affiliate sites.</p><p>Step by step they:</p><p>- Validated overlap in Search Console for 40 overlapping queries.<br>- Confirmed referral pathways using Traffic Analytics.<br>- Reallocated paid budget to product pages that matched the regional retailer&rsquo;s top landing pages.<br>- Launched a targeted outreach program to the same affiliates, using a narrower pitch that matched affiliate content styles.</p><p>Within six months, the retailer increased organic conversions for targeted categories by a measurable percentage and improved position on several high‑value product queries.</p><h2><b>Checklist: what to record during your first run</b></h2><p>- Seed list of domains (8-12)<br>- Domain Overview metrics (traffic, ranking keywords, referring domains)<br>- Keyword Gap exports (shared, unique counts)<br>- Top 30 overlapping, high‑intent queries<br>- Backlink notes for top landing pages<br>- Traffic seasonality and top referrers<br>- Validation outcomes (Search Console + GA4 checks)<br>- Priority list and next actions</p><h2><b>Frequently asked questions</b></h2><p><b>Q:</b> How accurate is Semrush for competitor analysis?<br><b>A:</b> Semrush is strong for directional insight, especially for mid‑to‑large sites. Its values are algorithmic estimates and can be off for low‑traffic or very niche sites. Always validate key findings with first‑party analytics.</p><p><b>Q:</b> Can I use Keyword Gap to find content opportunities?<br><b>A:</b> Yes - Keyword Gap shows keywords competitors rank for that you don&rsquo;t. Prioritize opportunities by commercial intent and potential conversion value.</p><p><b>Q:</b> How often should I run competitor analysis?<br><b>A:</b> Quarterly is sensible for many businesses; monthly for fast‑moving markets or when you run aggressive campaigns.</p><h2><b>Final guidelines and a reproducible routine</b></h2><p>To summarize the process into a routine: assemble your seed list, run Domain Overview, quantify overlap in Keyword Gap, inspect Positions and backlinks for the highest‑value shared keywords, validate with first‑party analytics, then prioritize actions. Repeat on a cadence that suits your business and track progress.</p><p>When you need help executing the technical or outreach work, a discreet partner that focuses on systems - not templates - can be valuable. <a href="/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Orvus</a>, for example, works closely with teams to convert analysis into architecture, funnels and automation that keep progress steady without noise.</p>

<figure class="special-image-standalone">
  <a href="/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">
    <img src="/img/blog/7ac53d7a356d418c.jpg" alt="Orvus Ltd. Logo" />
  </a>
</figure>

<div class="side-by-side image-2-right">
  <div class="side-text"><p>If you want, I can provide a ready‑to‑use spreadsheet template with recommended filters for Keyword Gap, suggested export columns and a simple layout to capture overlaps and validation checks. That template will let your team run this workflow in under an hour for a single competitor set.</p></div>
  <a href="/#about" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><img src="/img/blog/695f4b956f9fd125.jpg" alt="Minimal 2D vector infographic showing overlapping pie charts and an intent-focused pie slice with arrows on a #0B1E33 background for Semrush competitor analysis" /></a>
</div><h2><b>Where to go next</b></h2><p>If you want, I can provide a ready‑to‑use spreadsheet template with recommended filters for Keyword Gap, suggested export columns and a simple layout to capture overlaps and validation checks. That template will let your team run this workflow in under an hour for a single competitor set.</p><p><i>Curious to try it on your own set? Run a quick Domain Overview, pick the top 5 candidates and run Keyword Gap with commercial intent filters - you&rsquo;ll get immediate insight into who really competes for your buyers.</i></p><p><b>Parting thought:</b> Tools like Semrush give you measurements - the advantage comes from disciplined interpretation, prioritized action and regular validation.</p>